Repair vs. Replace
When to fix it.
When to let it go.
The 50% rule: if the repair costs more than half the price of a new unit, you're likely better off replacing. But the rule has exceptions — and knowing them saves you from a $1,200 purchase you didn't need.
Appliance
Repair Range
Replace Signal
Refrigerator
$150–$400
Compressor failure on unit > 12 years
Washer
$120–$340
Drum bearing failure on front-loader > 8 years
Dryer
$85–$280
Motor failure on unit > 10 years
Dishwasher
$110–$320
Control board failure on unit > 9 years
Oven / Range
$100–$390
Multiple component failures in 12 months
⚠ Note on Control Boards
Control board replacements are expensive ($200–$500 parts). Before approving, ask us whether the board is repairable or if a generic substitute exists — often it does, at 40% of OEM cost.
Free Download
Repair vs. Replace Guide
A 12-page PDF covering every major appliance category. Includes age-based decision trees, average part costs by brand, and the three questions to ask any technician before approving a repair.
Age vs. cost decision matrix for 8 appliance types
Average part costs for 6 major brands (GE, Whirlpool, Samsung, LG, Maytag, Bosch)
Red flags that signal a technician is upselling
How to read a repair invoice line by line
